Walking with my young daughter to school,
she asks, seemingly out of nowhere,
"What are words anyway?
What is a girl, or a tree, or the ocean?
To an animal, the words we use are just
sounds like any other sound."
And I, who have spent the better part
of a lifetime believing in the beauty
and possibility of language, of building these
small temples of measured sound,
can offer no reasonable defense against
such a pure distillation of truth.
Have I been exposed as a mere hack,
a mild mannered charlatan? I am strangely,
secretly wounded when she throws
out the question of ages: "Why are we here?
No one knows. The animals would know
because they were here long before humans.
We can't really understand their language
yet; but we could learn if we listened."
Which is all her father, poor simpleton, can
manage today, tagging along, listening
to all that we need not say.